Meinungen zu Punkt- und Ringrichtern

[Lord Krachah]

Mal wieder ein Update:Don Ackerman (Salido vs. Garcia (+)

Gwen Adair (Vargas vs. Omotoso (+); Charlo vs. Hopkins (-); Chavez vs. Vera (-)

Predrag Aleksic (Postol vs. Corley (+); Thompson vs. Solis (+); Zlaticanin vs. Burns (+)

Javier Alvarez (Andrade vs. Martirosyan (-)

Michael Ancona (Peterson vs. Jean (+)

Kazunobu Asao (Uchiyama vs. Kaneko (+)

Fernando Barboza (Terrazas vs. Mijares (+); Miura vs. Thompson (+)

Debra Barnes (Adamek vs. Cunningham (-)

Ingo Barrabas (Huck vs. Afolabi (+)

Paul Barry (Brook vs. Jones (+)

Massimiliano Bianco (Hernandez vs. Cunningham (+)

David Bilocerkowec (Sato vs. Lopez (+)

Dave Braslow (Cunningham vs. Mansour (+)

Miroslaw Brozio (Soliman vs. Sturm (+)

Adalaide Byrd (Garcia vs. Judah (+); Froch vs. Kessler (-); Martinez vs. Chavez (+); Rios vs. April (+); Trout vs. Cotto (-); Molina vs. Smith (-); Malignaggi vs. Judah (+); Santa Cruz vs. Mijares (+); Khan vs. Collazo (+); Brook vs. Porter (+)

Robert Byrd (Marquez vs. Alvardo (-)

Carla Caiz (Stiverne vs. Arreola (+); Chavez vs. Vera (-); Alexander vs. Karass (+)

Raul Caiz Jr (Donaire vs. Vetyeka (+)

Raul Caiz Sr (Bradley vs. Provodnikov (-)

Jerry Cantu (Bradley vs. Provodnikov (+); Trout vs. Rodriguez (+); Ward vs. Rodriguez (+)

Ruben Carrion (Chavez vs. Vera (+)

Guido Cavalleri (Gonzalez vs. Rojas (+)

Tim Cheatham (Fortuna vs. Rodriguez (+)

Charles Chenouf (N‘dam vs. Bursak (+)

Stanley Christodoulou (Rodriguez vs. Maderna (+); Trout vs. Alvarez (-); Martinez vs. Chavez (+); Povetkin vs. Huck (+); Geale vs. Sturm (+); John vs. Chonlatarn (-); Oosthuizen vs. Maderna (+); Maidana vs. Broner (+)

Franco Ciminale (Bellew vs. Chilemba (+)

Burt A. Clements (Yamanaka vs. Darchinyan (-); Molina vs. Smith (+); Beltran vs. Usmanee (+); Figueroa vs. Belmontes (-); Mayweather vs. Maidana (-); Dirrell vs. Bika (+)

Carlos Colon (Garcia vs. Herrera (-)

Samuel Conde Lopez (Peterson vs. Jean (+)

John Coyle (Povetkin vs. Huck (+)

Tony Crebs (Alexander vs. Karass (+)

Glen Rick Crocker (Chavez vs. Rubio (-)

Rey Danseco (Trout vs. Alvarez (+); Sato vs. Rungvisai (+)

Richard James Davies (Groves vs. Johnson (+); Burns vs. Beltran (-)

Jonathan Davis (Vargas vs. Omotoso (+); Donaire vs. Mathebula (+)

Garry Dean (Tomlinson vs. Klassen (+)

Richard DeCarufel (Stevenson vs. Fonfara (+)

Max DeLuca (Martinez vs. Murray (+); Abregu vs. Decarie (+); Tarver vs. Kayode (+); Guerrero vs. Aydin (+); Guerrero vs. Berto (+); Bika vs. Periban (+); Ward vs. Rodriguez (+); Malignaggi vs. Judah (+); Chavez vs. Vera (+); Marquez vs. Alvardo (+); Herrera vs. Perez (+); Brook vs. Porter (+)

David Denkin (Tarver vs. Kayode (+)

Marty Denkin (Bradley vs. Provodnikov (+); Stiverne vs. Arreola (+); Mares vs. Moreno (+); Charlo vs. Hopkins (-); Chavez vs. Vera (-)

Luis Arturo Doffi (Cuenca vs. Olmedo (-)

Robin Dolpierre (Klitschko vs. Chisora (-); Takam vs. Thompson (+)

Valerie Dorsett (Solis vs. Kameda (+)

Barry Druxman (Molina vs. Smith (+)

Norbert Duernberger (Helenius vs. Sprott (+)

Deon Dwarte (Donaire vs. Mathebula (-); Huck vs. Afolabi (+)

Phil Edwards (Khan vs. Diaz (+); Brook vs. Hatton (+)

Zoltan Enyedi (Huck vs. Afolabi (+); Crawford vs. Burns (+)

Luis Escalona (Igarashi vs. Jaro (+)

Nicolas Esnault (Perez vs. Takam (+)

Glenn Feldman (Alexander vs. Maidana (+); Broner vs. Malignaggi (+); Mchunu vs. Chambers (+); Klitschko vs. Povetkin (+); Bradley vs. Marquez (-); Beltran vs. Usmanee (+); Jennings vs. Perez (+)

Christophe Fernandez (Bellew vs. Chilemba (+)

Mauro Di Fiore (Cuadras vs. Rungvisai (-)

Mike Fitzgerald (Salgado vs. Barros (+); Frampton vs. Martinez (-)

Dick Flaherty (Hopkins vs. Dawson (+); Cuadras vs. Rungvisai (-)

Bela Florian (Klitschko vs. Chisora (-)

Fred Fluty (Crawford vs. Klimov (+)

Duane Ford (Rios vs. Alvardo (+); Mayweather vs. Guerrero (+); Chavez vs. Rubio (+); Alvarado vs. Herrera (+); Bradley vs. Pacquiao (-)

Howard John Foster (Brook vs. Hatton (+)

Joe Garcia (Solis vs. Kameda (+)

Ruben M. Garcia (Donaire vs. Vazquez (-)

Jean Gauthier (Perez vs. Takam (+)

Leo Gersel (Lundy vs. Olusegun (+)

Lisa Giampa (Beltran vs. Kim (+); Pacquiao vs. Rios (+); Herrera vs. Perez (+)

Ted Gimza (Klitschko vs. Povetkin (+)

Giustino Di Giovanni (N‘dam vs. Bursak (+); Huck vs. Arslan (-)

Arnold Golger (Bundu vs. Gavin (+)

Eliseo Gonzalez (Mosley vs. Cano (+)

Robert Gonzalez (Solis vs. Airich (+)

Eugene Grant (Geale vs. Sturm (-)

Steve Gray (Khan vs. Diaz (+); Brook vs. Jones (+); Fury vs. Johnson (+)

Mark Green (Guerrero vs. Aydin (+); Groves vs. Johnson (+)

Richard Green (Barthelemy vs. Mendez (+)

Dave Greer (Adamek vs. Cunningham (-)

Don Griffin (Williams vs. Ishida (+); Andrade vs. Martirosyan (-)

Andre Van Grootenbruel (Burns vs. Beltran (-)

Fabian Guggenheim (Bellew vs. Chilemba (+)

Timo Habighorst (Hammer vs. Johnson (-)

Glen Hamada (Green vs. Cameron (+)

Takeo Harada (Uchiyama vs. Kaneko (+)

Dave Hess (Vazquez vs. Diaz (+)

Nicolas Hidalgo (Martinez vs. Murray (+)

Anek Hongtongkam (Garcia vs. Judah (-)

Robert Hoyle (Martinez vs. Magdaleno (-); Tomlinson vs. Klassen (+); Chilemba vs. Miranda (+); Alvarado vs. Herrera (+); Mayweather vs. Cotto (+); Garcia vs. Matthysse (+); Bradley vs. Marquez (+); Solis vs. Kameda (+); Vargas vs. Allakhverdiev (-)

Joerg Ilinseer (Hammer vs. Johnson (-)

Gary Ingraham (Green vs. Cameron (+)

Rafael Isenia (Marquez vs. Fedchenko (+)

Jerry Jakubco (Molina vs. Spinks (+)

Leszek Jankowiak (Rodriguez vs. Maderna (+)

James Jen-Kin (Mares vs. Moreno (-)

Tammye Jenkins (Charlo vs. Rosado (+)

Ian John-Lewis (Postol vs. Lundy (+); Thompson vs. Solis (+)

Pawel Kardyni (Geale vs. Adama (+); Pulev vs. Thompson (+)

John Keane (Alexander vs. Maidana (+); Zlaticanin vs. Burns (-)

Chan-Soo Kim (Sato vs. Lopez (-)

Alan Krebs (Vargas vs. Allakhverdiev (+)

Manfred Kuechler (Brook vs. Jones (+); Pacquiao vs. Rios (+)

Ed Kugler (Mosley vs. Cano (+)

Salven Lagumbay (Crawford vs. Burns (+)

Fernando Laguna (Pirog vs. Ishida (+)

Juergen Langos (Garcia vs. Matthysse (+); Thompson vs. Solis (+)

Larry Layton (Vazquez vs. Diaz (+)

Sylvain Leblanc (Perez vs. Takam (+); Vazquez vs. Shafikov (-)

Julie Lederman (Salido vs. Garcia (+); Donaire vs. Rigondeaux (+); Mayweather vs. Guerrero (+); Guerrero vs. Berto (+); Bika vs. Periban (+); Perez vs. Abdusalamov (+); Porter vs. Alexander (+); Garcia vs. Burgos (+); Glazkov vs. Adamek (+); Marquez vs. Alvardo (+)

Al Lefkowitz (Chilemba vs. Miranda (+)

Jean-Louis Legland (Rodriguez vs. Maderna (+)

Esa Lehtosaari (Postol vs. Lundy (+); Postol vs. Corley (+); Murray vs. Bursak (+)

Cathy Leonard (Terrazas vs. Mijares (+); Khan vs. Collazo (+); Cuadras vs. Rungvisai (-)

Bill Lerch (Molina vs. Spinks (+); Rios vs. Alvardo (+); Quillin vs. Konecny (+)

Mihai Leu (Hammer vs. Johnson (-)

Alex Levin (Barthelemy vs. Mendez (+)

Jun-Bae Lim (Sato vs. Rungvisai (+)

Barry Lindenman (Takam vs. Thompson (+)

Alejandro Lopez Cid (Hernandez vs. Cunningham (+); Marquez vs. Fedchenko (+); Crawford vs. Burns (+)

Victor Loughlin (Bellew vs. Chilemba (+)

Charlie Lucas (Geale vs. Mundine (-)

John Madfis (Pirog vs. Ishida (+); Huck vs. Afolabi (+)

Tony Marretta (Geale vs. Mundine (+)

Francisco Martinez (John vs. Chonlatarn (-); Donaire vs. Vetyeka (+)

Levi Martinez (Martinez vs. Magdaleno (+); Donaire vs. Vazquez (+); Maidana vs. Broner (+); Donaire vs. Vetyeka (+); Crawford vs. Uzcategui (+); Alvarez vs. Lara (+)

Marcus McDonnell (Fury vs. Johnson (+); Frampton vs. Martinez (+)

John McKaie (Vazquez vs. Gesta (+); Bute vs. Grachev (+); Lara vs. Trout (+); Santa Cruz vs. Mijares (+); Stevenson vs. Fonfara (+)

David Mendoza (Igarashi vs. Jaro (+); Figueroa vs. Belmontes (-)

Erkki Meronen (Alexeev vs. Licina (+)

Craig Metcalfe (Abregu vs. Decarie (+); Mayweather vs. Alvarez (+); Pacquiao vs. Bradley (+)

Joerg Milke (Helenius vs. Sprott (+)

Tom Miller (Adamek vs. Cunningham (+); Salgado vs. Barros (+); Broner vs. Malignaggi (+)

Jorge Dionisio Millicay (Cuenca vs. Olmedo (-)

Hubert Minn (Gonzalez vs. Rojas (+); Figueroa vs. Belmontes (+)

Omar Mintun (Sosa vs. Segura (+)

Michael Mitchell (Williams vs. Ishida (+)

Noel Monnet (Pirog vs. Ishida (+); Abraham vs. Stieglitz (+)

Matteo Montella (Baysangurov vs. Konecny (-)

Lou Moret (Sato vs. Lopez (+)

Dave Moretti (Rios vs. Alvardo (+); Chilemba vs. Miranda (+); Martinez vs. Chavez (+); Alvarado vs. Herrera (+); Mayweather vs. Cotto (+); Tarver vs. Kayode (+); Lara vs. Martirosyan (+); Beltran vs. Kim (+): Mayweather vs. Alvarez (+); Beltran vs. Usmanee (+); Mayweather vs. Maidana (-); Fortuna vs. Rodriguez (+); Alvarez vs. Lara (+); Dirrell vs. Bika (+)

Kevin Morgan (Glazkov vs. Adamek (+)

Patrick Morley (Molina vs. Spinks (+)

Steve Morrow (Donaire vs. Mathebula (-); Yamanaka vs. Darchinyan (-); Ward vs. Rodriguez (+); Yaegashi vs. Sosa (+); Dirrell vs. Bika (+)

Patricia Morse Jarman (Vazquez vs. Gesta (+); Mayweather vs. Cotto (+); Porter vs. Diaz (+); Bradley vs. Marquez (+); Vazquez vs. Shafikov (+)

Thomas Nardone (Gonzalez vs. Rojas (+)

Dennis Nelson (Korobov vs. Uzcategui (+); Frampton vs. Martinez (-)

Mike Nolan (Lundy vs. Olusegun (+)

Terry O'Connor (Khan vs. Diaz (+); Alexeev vs. Licina (+); Fury vs. Johnson (+)

Richard Ocasio (Lara vs. Martirosyan (+); Porter vs. Diaz (+)

Humberto Olivares (Sosa vs. Segura (+)

Carlos Ortiz Jr (Mchunu vs. Chambers (+); Barker vs. Geale (+); Burns vs. Beltran (-)

Lahcen Oumghar (Baysangurov vs. Konecny (-); Huck vs. Afolabi (+)

Gustavo Padilla (Garcia vs. Herrera (-)

Nathan Palmer (Terrazas vs. Mijares (-)

Juan Carlos Palmieri (Abregu vs. Decarie (-)

Manuel Oliver Palomo (Bundu vs. Gavin (+)

Tony Paolillo (Martinez vs. Burgos (+)

Eddie Pappoe (Bellew vs. Chilemba (-); Klitschko vs. Chisora (-)

Claude Paquette (Stiverne vs. Arreola (+); Bute vs. Grachev (+); Pascal vs. Bute (+)

Dave Parris (Geale vs. Adama (+); Geale vs. Sturm (+); Brook vs. Hatton (+); Groves vs. Johnson (+); Oosthuizen vs. Maderna (+); Brook vs. Porter (+)

Joseph Pasquale (Adamek vs. Chambers (+); Jennings vs. Perez (+)

Juan Carlos Pelayo (Sosa vs. Segura (+); Yamanaka vs. Darchinyan (-)

Barbara Perez (Barker vs. Geale (+)

Michael Pernick (Martinez vs. Magdaleno (+); Allakhverdiev vs. Guzman (+); Crawford vs. Klimov (+); Pacquiao vs. Rios (+); Malignaggi vs. Judah (+); Garcia vs. Burgos (+); Abraham vs. Stieglitz (+); Pacquiao vs. Bradley (+); Quillin vs. Konecny (+); Mayweather vs. Maidana (+)

Charles Phillips (Solis vs. Airich (-)

Olena Pobyvailo (Murray vs. Bursak (+)

Pete Podgorski (Heerden vs. Lujan (+)

John Poturaj (Hopkins vs. Cloud (+); Trout vs. Cotto (+); Lara vs. Trout (+); Garcia vs. Burgos (+); Glazkov vs. Adamek (+); Cunningham vs. Mansour (+); Soliman vs. Sturm (+)

Pasquale Procopio (Hernandez vs. Cunningham (+); Pascal vs. Bute (+); Peterson vs. Jean (+)

Steve Rados (Charlo vs. Rosado (+); Quillin vs. Konecny (+)

Cesar Ramos (Alexander vs. Maidana (+); Abraham vs. Stieglitz (+)

Rafael Ramos (Solis vs. Airich (-)

Bill Ray (Barthelemy vs. Mendez (+)

Ray Reed (Geale vs. Mundine (+)

Jesse Reyes (Alvarez vs. Mosley (-); Andrade vs. Martirosyan (+)

Gerald Ritter (Zlaticanin vs. Burns (+)

Luis Rivera (Hopkins vs. Dawson (+)

Alejandro Rochin (Martinez vs. Murray (+); Trout vs. Rodriguez (-); Guerrero vs. Berto (+); Garcia vs. Herrera (-)

Waleska Roldan (Martinez vs. Burgos (-); Thurman vs Zaveck (+); Mitchell vs. Banks (+); Porter vs. Alexander (+)

Luis Romio (Cuenca vs. Olmedo (+)

C.J. Ross (Vazquez vs. Gesta (+); Alvarez vs. Mosley (+); Bradley vs. Pacquiao (-); Mayweather vs. Alvarez (-)

Mike Ross (Mitchell vs. Banks (+)

Jerry Roth (Mayweather vs. Guerrero (+); Rios vs. April (-); Bradley vs. Pacquiao (+); Lara vs. Martirosyan (+); Beltran vs. Kim (+); Vargas vs. Allakhverdiev (+); Khan vs. Collazo (+); Fortuna vs. Rodriguez (+); Alvarez vs. Lara (+)

Benoit Roussel (Sturm vs. Soliman (-); Oosthuizen vs. Maderna (+)

Alan Rubenstein (Adamek vs. Chambers (-); Barker vs. Geale (+); Cunningham vs. Mansour (-)

Clark Sammartino (Abraham vs. Stieglitz (+)

Marty Sammon (Sato vs. Rungvisai (+)

Herb Santos (Porter vs. Diaz (+)

Tom Schreck (Hopkins vs. Cloud (+); Donaire vs. Rigondeaux (+); Garcia vs. Judah (+); Broner vs. Malignaggi (-); Lara vs. Trout (+); Jennings vs. Perez (+)

Rainer Schwarz (Helenius vs. Sprott (+)

Joel Scobie (Miura vs. Thompson (-); Yaegashi vs. Sosa (+)

Ian Scott (Geale vs. Adama (+)

Steve Scott (Tomlinson vs. Klassen (+); Green vs. Cameron (-)

Oren Shellenberger (Trout vs. Alvarez (+); Williams vs. Ishida (+); Miura vs. Thompson (+); Yaegashi vs. Sosa (+)

Takeshi Shimakawa (John vs. Chonlatarn (+); Uchiyama vs. Kaneko (+)

Kyung-Ha Shin (Igarashi vs. Jaro (+)

John Signorile (Martinez vs. Burgos (+)

Jeff Sinnett (Korobov vs. Uzcategui (+)

Wayne Smith (Charlo vs. Rosado (+)

John Stewart (Salido vs. Garcia (+); Hopkins vs. Cloud (+); Donaire vs. Rigondeaux (-); Perez vs. Abdusalamov (+); Porter vs. Alexander (+)

Mark Streisand (Allakhverdiev vs. Guzman (+); Heerden vs. Lujan (+)

Carlos Sucre (Froch vs. Kessler (+)

David Sutherland (Mares vs. Moreno (+); Chavez vs. Vera (+)

Robert Tapper (Mosley vs. Cano (+)

Michael Tate (Guerrero vs. Aydin (+)

Robin Taylor (Bika vs. Periban (-)

Paul Thomas (Huck vs. Afolabi (+); Huck vs. Arslan (-); Abraham vs. Stieglitz (+)

Jean-Francois Toupin (Froch vs. Kessler (+); Alexeev vs. Licina (+)

Don Trella (Thurman vs Zaveck (+); Donaire vs. Vazquez (+); N‘dam vs. Bursak (+); Mitchell vs. Banks (+); Mchunu vs. Chambers (+); Pulev vs. Thompson (+); Perez vs. Abdusalamov (+); Soliman vs. Sturm (+)

Peter Trematerra (Crawford vs. Klimov (+)

Glenn Trowbridge (Rios vs. April (-); Alvarez vs. Mosley (-); Salgado vs. Barros (+); Garcia vs. Matthysse (+); Santa Cruz vs. Mijares (+); Pacquiao vs. Bradley (-); Herrera vs. Perez (+)

Isaac Tshabalala (Heerden vs. Lujan (+)

Mickey Vann (Sturm vs. Soliman (+); Huck vs. Arslan (-); Baysangurov vs. Konecny (-); Pulev vs. Thompson (-)

Nelson Vazquez (Thurman vs Zaveck (+); Allakhverdiev vs. Guzman (+); Maidana vs. Broner (+)

Philippe Verbeke (Povetkin vs. Huck (+); Klitschko vs. Povetkin (+)

Robert Verwijs (Bundu vs. Gavin (-)

Fernando Villareal (Alexander vs. Karass (+)

Marshall Walker (Trout vs. Rodriguez (+)

Steve Weisfeld (Sturm vs. Soliman (+); Marquez vs. Fedchenko (+); Hopkins vs. Dawson (+); Trout vs. Cotto (+); Adamek vs. Chambers (+)

Frank Wells (Lundy vs. Olusegun (+)

Fritz Werner (Vargas vs. Omotoso (+); Charlo vs. Hopkins (-)

Daniel Van de Wiele (Postol vs. Lundy (+); Bellew vs. Chilemba (+); Postol vs. Corley (+); Takam vs. Thompson (+); Murray vs. Bursak (+)

Al Wilensky (Vazquez vs. Diaz (+)

Chris Wilson (Vazquez vs. Shafikov (+)

Jack Woodburn (Chavez vs. Rubio (+); Bute vs. Grachev (+); Pascal vs. Bute (+); Stevenson vs. Fonfara (+)

Rocky Young (Abraham vs. Stieglitz (+)

 

[PsychoGamer]

Die 20 besten Punktrichter, laut dieser Liste:

Max DeLuca = +12
Dave Moretti = +12

Julie Lederman = +10
Michael Pernick = +10

Don Trella = +8

John Poturaj = +7
Jerry Roth = +7

Levi Martinez = +6
Dave Parris = +6

Patricia Morse Jarman = +5
Glenn Feldman = +5
Robert Hoyle = +5
John McKaie = +5
Steve Weisfeld = +5
Daniel Van de Wiele = +5

Jack Woodburn = +4
Adalaide Byrd = +4
Stanley Christodoulou = +4
Tom Schreck = +4
Oren Shellenberger = +4

Die Grünen sind heute bei Mayweather-Maidana dabei, ebenfalls noch Guido Cavalleri (+1) da wird es hoffentlich keine Fehlentscheidung geben!

 

[Lord Krachah]

Super Auswertung, danke! Aber komisch, dass die Cavalleri für so einen Kampf benutzen. Der ist ja nun wirklich eher als Ringrichter bekannt.